10 Mistakes to Avoid When Buying Printer Ink

Are you tired of feeling like you’re overpaying for printer ink? You’re not alone.


Many consumers unknowingly make simple mistakes that lead to wasted money, poor print results, or frustration at the checkout. If you’ve ever struggled to figure out the correct cartridge or wondered if that cheap online deal was too good to be true, this guide is for you.


We’ll walk through the top 10 mistakes to avoid when buying printer ink and show you how to make smarter, cost-effective decisions.


1. Ignoring Printer Compatibility

One of the biggest missteps is assuming “close enough” will work.

Every printer requires a specific cartridge model. Always check your printer’s manual or the manufacturer’s support site before buying. For example, if your printer calls for the HP 64XL, using a different cartridge could leave you stuck with a product you can’t use.


2. Not Understanding High-Yield (XL) vs. Standard Cartridges

Standard cartridges may cost less up front, but they don’t last as long. High-yield cartridges, like the HP 64XL, provide more ink at a lower cost per page, helping you save money on ink in the long run.


3. Falling for “Too Good to Be True” Deals

Ultra-cheap prices can be tempting, but they often mean the product isn’t genuine. This can lead to poor reliability or wasted money if the cartridge doesn’t work correctly. That’s why at Ink Genie, we sell only genuine OEM ink from trusted brands like HP, Canon, Brother, and Epson.


4. Buying From Untrusted Sources

Some online sellers offer low prices but don’t stand behind their products. Without a reliable return policy, you’re taking a risk that could cost you more later.


5. Assuming All Colors Are Needed

Many printers use either tri-color cartridges or individual colors. If your printer uses individual cartridges, replacing only the empty color can save money on ink over time.


6. Neglecting Customer Reviews and Guarantees

Ignoring feedback or return policies is a mistake. Reviews confirm reliability, while guarantees protect your purchase if something goes wrong. As a family-owned company, Ink Genie values every customer, and our Ink Genie Guarantee ensures you’re never stuck with a cartridge that doesn’t meet your needs.


7. Not Knowing the Difference Between Ink and Toner

Ink is used in inkjet printers, while toner is used in laser printers. Mixing them up leads to unnecessary returns and delays.


8. Ignoring Expiration or Manufacture Dates

Some buyers see dates printed on cartridges and assume the ink has expired. In reality, genuine cartridges are designed to last well beyond those dates if stored properly.


9. Failing to Buy in Bulk

Buying single cartridges over and over adds up quickly. For frequent users, multi-packs offer better value and help prevent last-minute trips to the store.


10. Using the Wrong Print Settings

Even the best cartridge won’t last if your printer settings aren’t optimized. Switching to draft mode for everyday documents can extend the life of cartridges like the HP 64XL significantly.


Shop Smarter and Skip Common Ink Buying Mistakes 


Buying printer ink doesn’t have to be complicated or costly. By avoiding these common mistakes, such as checking compatibility, choosing high-yield options, and buying from trusted sources, you’ll save money and enjoy better results.


At Ink Genie, we’ve built our business to help you avoid all of these mistakes. From transparent pricing and genuine OEM products to personalized customer service, we’re here to make sure your printing experience is hassle-free.


Whether you’re ordering the HP 64XL ink cartridge or stocking up for your office, you’ll always find the lowest prices and the confidence of our satisfaction guarantee.

Ready to shop smarter? Find genuine ink and toner at the lowest prices, backed by unbeatable customer care at Ink Genie.